Some of you may already know me from YouTube or Instagram, or very recently, from Cakelosophy Facebook page. For the rest of you, I’m hoping that my write-up will double up as a bit of an introduction, too.
In this test, I tried out 11 pots of gold. 10 of them are fully edible by UK reg., mostly lustre dusts mixed with vodka, but also a paint, a paste and a spray. I also included 1 non-edible dust, as I was curious to see if it was really that different.
I used 4 dried squares of fondant for most tests: white/ yellowish fondant base with 1 and 2 layers of paint.
When mixing edible dusts with vodka, I tried to make my paint as rich as possible...Here's my YOUTUBE vid to show live coverage of the tested paint (SCROLL DOWN for TRUE TO LIFE gold shots)
You might find that the pictures of golds tested are plenty enough to give you an idea of what’s what. I took all pics in the same spot of daylight and did not use filters. If you are interested, however, I rated each of my golds on SHADE, COVERAGE and it’s SPARKLE-ability see the comments under the pics.
Some of the results totally surprised me! Be sure to see the conclusion at the bottom, for my BEST and WORST golds and more.
Without further ado, let's get started.
*All prices quoted, are from the same place ( Ebay ) and include postage.
First Dig...
1. METALLIC GOLDEN SANDS
...dust in the Edible Silk Range, by RAINBOW DUST. Price £2.95 for 4 g pot.
+ SHADE: Not great too orange, looks orangy in a pot, too.
+ COVERAGE: Solid but streaky; 2 layers did not quite solve it, yet it’s likely that 3 layers may interfere with the pattern, quite clumpy, probably more than average drying time.
+SPARKLE: Medium to low.
As I was saying... The shade is a ‘no-no’ for me to bother dealing with the rest.
Second Dig...
2. ANTIQUE GOLD
...edible lustre by SUGARFLAIR. £2.25 for 2 g pot
+SHADE: It’s unusual in a good way, imho, would work nice mixed with pearl lustre.
+COVERAGE: Not great, 1 layer is a ‘no-no’, 2 layers is ok , but can see streaks, I’d say matching base closely coud be an idea. It clumps up ‘medium-ly’. ( apologies for adjusting the lovely English words to own needs) . Dries quite quickly.
+SPARKLE: Medium to low.
As I was saying... this one is a very distinctive colour for a brave caker!
Third Dig...
3. GOLD SPARKLE
...edible lustre by SUGARFLAIR, £2.25 for 2 g pot.
+SHADE: I think it’s very good, true to light gold I imagine, anyway. Beware, it does look very similar to other Sugarflair gold dusts when you try to buy it online, very non-distinct shade when dry.
+COVERAGE: Very even, though not solid, its sparkle effect hides areas with less paint very well. It doesn’t clump up at all, so while 2 layers might not be enough from the draditional point of view, it could easily pass off as the modern ‘is it on purpose or they just can’t do it’ effect. Dries very quickly.
+SPARKLE: Fantastic Sparkletastic.
As I was saying... 3 layers with this one will not be clumpy and obstructive but is timely and more expensive.
Forth Dig...
4. GOLD
...dust food colour by SQUIRES KITCHEN £4.50 per pot of 5.5g
+SHADE: Heavy orange tint, NOT obvious by looking a the dry dust, even in a shop, never mind online.
+COVERAGE: Quite solid but streaky, similar to ‘Metallic Golden Sands’, and it’s clumpier than average.
+SPARKLE: Hardly any.
As I was saying...Expected much more of this make, as I love their image and bought some great stuff like impressive veiners from there, but not with this one. One thing, though, I remember it as being expensive, but it isn’t, if you pay attention to the gram/price ratio.
Fifth Dig...
5. LIGHT GOLD
...Pearl Dusting, dust Colour by COLOUR SPLASH, £5-6 for a 5 g pot
+SHADE: Light gold, similar to how it looks dry , good ‘lighthearted’ colour.
+COVERAGE: Not bad, not solid, but 2 layers will do a decent job, it clumps up moderately, not problematic.
+SPARKLE: Quite decent.
As I was saying... This one seems very similar to, but if applying dry, NOT as effective as most SUGARFLAIR dusts, I used.
Sixth Dig...
6. SAINSBURY’S
...gold ‘dust’. About £2.00 per pot.
+SHADE: Seems ok, ‘goldy’ and sparkly while in packaging, but when mixed with vodka, it’s a bit like wet sugar, has very odd, 'clingy' in all the wrong places, texture.
+COVERAGE: Pretty rubbish , slightly grainy and hardly visible, yellowish in colour that can be seen in some places but not other. Clumping up doesn’t apply here, it’s just all wrong.
SPARKLE: None whatsoever, once liquified. If pplying dry ( I did ), it's a bit like using sand, again, and it’s heavy, too. Did anywone use it happily, I wonder, and how so?
As I was saying... Looks inviting when dry but don’t be fooled, it seems to do the opposite of what you expect it to, on every count, epic golden fail, basically. (On balance, I do like Saisbury’s Pizzas and their gluten free flour ain’t half bad!)
Seventh Dig...
7. PASTEL GOLD
...edible lustre by SUGARFLAIR, £2.25 for 2 g pot
+SHADE: Good, true to its name. This one, too, looks very similar to other Sugarflair gold dusts when dry.
+COVERAGE: Very even, though not solid. 2 layers’ may not be enough but 3 would work just fine, it hardly clumps up, so one problem less there, too.
+SPARKLE: Yes. Or at least a ‘full on’ shimmer.
As I was saying... Good all-rounder. I especially like how it looks as the first layer under two layers of ‘Gold Sparkle’ by Sugarflair *( The odd square on the 5 squares’ pic! )
Eighth Dig..
8. METALLIC GOLD
...edible food PAINT by COLOUR SPLASH, £5.00 for a 25g pot ( heavier, being a paint)
+ SHADE: Very nice, bright gold.
+COVERAGE: Good, the only edible with one layer being enough, probably. It’s quite thick, two layers might obscure very delicate pattern. On a flat surface the brush lines are hard to avoid, but might work really well for rustic look. Takes longer than dusts to dry but the brushes are as easy to clean as with dusts, which was a nice surprise.
+SPARKLE: Excellent.
As I was saying...When applying watch out for bubbles.
Ninth Dig...
9. GOLD
...paste by SUGARFLAIR. £3.80 for a regular SF paste pot.
+SHADE: Horrendous. I don’t seem myself bonding with it under any trend.
+COVERAGE: Very patchy, not improving much with the second layer, but managing to obstruct bits of pattern all the same.
+SPARKLE: Hardly there when applied ( seems stunning while in the pot, but without diluting with vodka , it’s too ‘heavy’ to be applied, which is just as well, as it woud have costed tons)
As I was saying...Maybe you are supposed to use this to colour the base fondnat? But if so, why waste time with the sparkly effect in the bottle, which would never show up if added in fondant mix?
Tenth Dig...
10. PME
...edible lustre spray GOLD. £6.79 per a spray can
+SHADE: Ok, a bit orangy. NOT at all as it looks on a can, which can be a bummer, considering that it’s not cheap.
+COVERAGE: Quite easy to use on testers once you got hang of the right distance and pace, but I see it being a disadvantage for cakes as it spreads around quite a bit, though perhaps I’m just not used to the medium and the whole masking thing is worth it, the rest being quick and easy.
+SPARKLE: Not bad, more like a shimmer, but is definitely there.
As I was saying...For me, it wouldn’t have been worth the price, but I never use cans to spray. If I do, I’ll post more on it.
Final , NON - EDIBLE Dig...
10. Golden Rose
...the non-edible DECORATIVE gold dust about £2.80 a pot.
+SHADE: Out of this world, but the big BUT.
+COVERAGE: Pretty solid with one layer, though I’d use two ( run out of squares, hence no second layer).
+SPARKLE: Total bling, as you can see.
As I was saying...One use for it I can immediately think of, would be a custom cake board, ( have vid for on of these on my youtube, sorry to self-prom) though you’d need something stupidly bright on a cake itself to counterbalance, or else everyone will just stare at the board, nevermind what else.
My BEST and the WORST and the rest...
The BEST edible gold paint for me out of this lot, was ‘GOLD SPARKLE’ by Sugarflair.
True to its name, it was the gold that sparkled the most, the shade was very jolly and gold-like and the coverage came out very even and was easy to apply.
My WORST eidble gold was a close call between the confused dust from Sainsbury’s and the paste ‘Gold’ by Sugarflair. Sugarflair has at least one more gold paste that I know of, called ‘Honey Gold’ so my mind boggles as to why they dicided to call this one simply ‘Gold’. Go and have another look at it: surely this particular shade coudn’t have been their idea of ultimate gold? But here goes. I will go for Sainsbury’s offering as being the WORST, though. At least one can use Sugarflair as a base colour, while, havig applied all imagination at my disposal, I still can’t think of how to use the other one with any good effect.
On another note, the non-edible paint is very impressive, but I’d just double-checked, and it contains ‘copper’ , which makes it a bit of a non-event, as I could have bought something of this sort in Hobbycraft, or is it any better? It looks like it could be edible…. Is there any difference between this £1.60 per pot Golden Rose and the $30.00 ‘Ideale’ that is classified as ‘not regulated by the FDA as a food product, so it should only be used on decorations and parts of the cake that will not be eaten’ as put up for sale by the Evil Cake Genius (on my 'Cake: Sourcing Materials' Pinterest Board). Because if ‘Ideale’ also gets it’s ‘goldness’ from copper, without saying that much, then maybe everyone shuld just start using Golden Rose, cheap and cheerful, and be done with it? I’ll just leave this for another blog post, shall I...
And so to finish off ...
I’m definitiely not claiming to be an expert gold-digger, just sugarcraft curious ( and this will apply to the vast majority of what I’ll blog about, I’m afraid to say, my gallery and social media should should convey my strenghts and limitations if anyone’s interested in my cred or lack thereof), so I’d LOVE TO HEAR about your experiences and takes on food grade Gold in UK and abroad. Do GO to the pink button below and COMMENT! Commenting and hearing back is fun, once you get started.
Does anyone use the vaguely deifined seemingly edible gold for things like sugar flowers, for example? I know I did. If to order, I explained and got written consent.
How about using gold in other coutries? Where in the world are you lucky enough to use this faboulous gold dust that looks incredible on insta pictures of cupcakes and makes all UK cakes green with envy?
And this is about it for this post, sorry it was a bit too long and hope you enjoyed it. Thanks for reading and participating. I’m planning to do at least one more ‘gold-digging’ post in the future.
...These and more...
No comments
Post a Comment